Histories of Arab Documentary
Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München Institut für Kunstgeschichte & Filmmuseum/Münchner Stadtmuseum,
October 27 - 29, 2017
Friday, Oct. 27, 2017 panels and film screening (9:00-18:0)
Saturday Oct. 28, 2017 panels and film screening (9:00-18:00)
Sunday Oct. 29, 2017 film screening only (18.00)
The conference Histories of Arab Documentary wants to examine the diverse histories of film documentary in the MENA region since the 1920s and to serve as a platform for investigating different theoretical approaches with regards to a number of queries, that is: structural development and state intervention, formats and aesthetics, new media, politics of representation, auteurs and subjectivity, „Artivism" and Revolution. It will allow film professionals from the region and international academic researchers to meet and exchange on their respective topics. Herewith it will unearth and propel some of the hitherto unrecognized scholarly work in the field and to shed light on a neglected part of general film history.
Institut für Kunstgeschichte
Zentnerstr. 31 80798 München room 007
How to reach:
Subway: Line U2 stop Josephsplatz or Hohenzollernplatz Bus: 154 stop Winzererstraße
Filmmuseum/Münchner Stadtmuseum St.-Jakobs-Platz 1
How to reach:
S/U-Bahn stop Marienplatz U-Bahn stop Sendlinger Tor Bus 62 stop St.-Jakobs-Platz Bus 52 stop Blumenstraße
DAY ONE: Friday Oct. 27, 17
9:00 - 9:15
Introduction: Dr. Viola Shafik & Prof. Dr. Kerstin Pinther (organisers)
9:15 - 10:30
Histories and Structures
Laura Marks (researcher/Simon-Fraser University, Canada)
Political economies of experimental documentary
How do makers manage the balance between reaching audiences and protecting their civil and intel- lectual-property rights? I will draw on case studies of exhibition venues, distribution and artists' rights.
Kay Dickinson (Concordia University, Canada)
Funding the “Creative Documentary”: An Art Cinema of Refugees
While Arab documentaries are usually categorized in national terms, their funding is often complex- ly transnational. The selection processes the Dubai International Film Festival enacts to distribute production support to non-UAE filmmakers reveals how the pressing subject of refugee representa- tion is marshaled according to often conflicting economic imperatives that aim to expand the cre- ative economies of the UAE.
10:45 - 12:30
Artivisim and Revolution
Jamal Bahmad (postdoctoral fellow, UK/Morocco):
From Mount Albban to the World: Artivism and the Environmental Documentary in Morocco
Morocco’s longest sit-in is still on-going on Mount Albban (Tinghir province), which overlooks Af- rica’s largest silver mine in the village of Imider. The sit-in started in 2011 hand in hand with the so- called Arab Spring. The protesters on Mount Albban since 2011 have been filming their everyday life and protests against the repression of the authorities, which have arrested and imprisoned many activists over the last six years.The Mount Albban sit-in has also also attracted a brave Moroccan documentary filmmaker, Nadir Bouhmouch. This paper will explore Bouhmouch’s films, which are indeed two powerful illustrations of artivism and will likely define this new genre in Morocco. The paper will conclude with the implications of this formative moment for the future of environmental politics in Morocco and perhaps beyond.
Nouri Gana (researcher/UCLA, USA)
The Will to Expose: Documentary Filmmaking in Postrevolutionary Tunisia
Sami Tlili’s Yal‘in bu il-Phosphate (Cursed be the Phosphate) is just one example about how the will to document for revolutionary purposes has gradually gone quite quotidian—transforming in the process into an everyday will-to-expose. I argue throughout this article that the will-to-expose has become indeed the driving force of documentary filmmaking in Postrevolutionary Tunisia. In other words, documentary filmmaking has matured enormously in a very compressed period of time and become not only a tool of criticism (i.e., criticism with definite and specific targets like the former dictator and his regime), but also a tool of critique (i.e., the kind of critical work that is more profoundly aware of the complicated web of power-interrelations of which the current condition of Tunisia as an economically-dependent country is an effect).
Donatella della Ratta (Assistant Professor of Media Studies, John Cabot University, Rome):
“The Unbearable Lightness of Images”: The Aesthetics, Economics, and Politics of Post-2011 Filmmaking in Syria
The talk will frame the analysis on contemporary image making in Syria – from user-generated videos by activists and citizen journalists to fully fledged auter films – within a broader reflection on the web 2.0 as the technological and social infrastructure dramatically influencing the aesthetics and politics of Syrian visual media. Questions related to the political economy of networked communication technologies will be explored, such as Syrian image-makers' loss of ownership and control over their own visual production; and the corporate and private nature of web platforms controlling the flow of data on Internet and establishing what ought to be remembered and archived as a meaningful “past”, and what to be removed, redacted, and therefore forgotten among the events currently unfolding in Syria.
12:30-13:15 lunch break 13:15 - 14:30
The Filmmaker and the State
Ali Essafi (filmmaker/author, Casa Blanca):
Short History of Moroccan Non-Fiction Film
The non- fiction Moroccan cinema was born, by default, with the first generation of filmmakers emerging just after the country’s independence by the end of the 1950s. However in the following decade the lack of cultural freedom and distribution networks condemns the young cinematographic movement to a slow death. And then, since the early 1970s total inertia until twenty years later a new generation comes to life. Exclusively active in the western countries and disconnected from the first generation’s legacy, this one painfully tries to build a unique cinematographic identity.
Yasmin Desouki: (researcher/ Cimatheque Cairo)
Egyptian Newsreels and Beyond
I am thinking of writing primarily about newsreels and the general tendency to "document" in different forms of Egyptian media—there is often a direct link between newsreels, some commercials made for different state institutions (especially those written and directed by Ahmed Kamel Awad, which borrow elements of docu-fiction), and some of the documentaries Hossam Ali made, produced by the Ministry of Culture. And while newsreels are primarily a form of documentation, there is also a slightly "staged" quality to them that might be interesting to explore further, particularly how they also influenced the commercials of Ahmed Kamel Awad and other filmmakers. The loose timeframe for the pieces I'm discussing is 1962-1982.
14:45 - 16:00
Directors and Formats
Shohini Chaudhuri (Senior Lecturer, University of Essex, UK)
Iraq War Home Movies: Abbas Fahdel's Homeland (Iraq War Zero)
Filmmaker Abbas Fahdel filmed his family and acquaintances before, during and after the US-led invasion of Iraq. The result is Homeland (Iraq Year Zero) (2015), a five-and-a-half hour documenta- ry in two parts that presents the Iraq War as a home movie from an Iraqi perspective. This chapter will explore how the film uses its home-movie aesthetic to address the lacunae of mainstream (Wes- tern) coverage of the war as well as to articulate specificities of Iraqi life under Saddam Hussein's dictatorship. Homeland raises a number of comparisons with other long-format documentaries, such as Shoah and Route 181: Fragments of a Journey in Palestine-Israel, while Fahdel has himself li- kened its portrayal of a war-devastated landscape to the Zone in Tarkovsky's Stalker. The chapter will focus on sensations of space and time created by the film as it strives to unearth another reality of Iraq that was lost upon the country's American invaders.
Peter Limbrick (Associate Professor of Film and Digital Media, University of California, Santa Cruz, USA)
Spaces of dispossession: experiments with the real in contemporary Algerian cinema
This paper will address the rhetorics of dispossession and space in contemporary Algerian films. While paying particular attention to two recent documentaries, Un rond point dans ma tête (Hassan Ferhani, 2015) and Samir dans la poussière (Mohamed Ouzine, 2015), my paper situates them in relation to other documentary and fiction films, both Algerian and non-Algerian, that also experi- ment with how to articulate the social and political realities of the present.
Presented by Ali Essafi/Viola Shafik/Kerstin Pinther
- Let the World Witness/fa li-yashhad al-'alam by Saad Nadim (1956, Egypt, 20 min) - Memoire 14 von Ahmed Bouanani (1971, Morocco, 24 min) by Ahmed Bouanani
- Zerda and the Songs of Oblivion/La Zerda et les chants des l’oubli by Assia Djebar (1982, Algeria, 26min)
DAY TWO: Saturday Oct. 28, 17
9:00 - 10:45
Politics of Representation I
Ella Shohat (Professor/ New York University & Affiliated with NYU-Abu Dhabi)
On Palestine and the Arab-Jew: The Cinema of Displacement
Shohat discusses the representation of the links between the question of Palestine and that of the Arab-Jew in revisionist documentaries. She examines the critique of Zionist discourses, on the one hand, and of Arab nationalism, on the other, in relation to the history of partition and the disposses- sion of Palestinians and the dislocation of Arab-Jews — all within diasporic and transnational per- spectives.
Nisreen Mansour (researcher/Westminster University)
The Aesthetics of Othering in Lebanese War Documentaries
I am thinking of a piece that explores the aesthetics of othering in Lebanese war documentaries in the context of the Sabra and Chatila massacres or the unresolved fate of thousands of disappeared civilians. It will engage in a close reading of key works produced during and after the official end of the civil war. The narrative shifts of victimhood and perpetration will be traced across time in an effort to understand the discursive appeal of the genre.
Nadia Yaqub (professor/University of North Carolina)
Opaque Encounters in Films About Palestine
A paper on the use of the experimental essay film as a means of addressing the problem of the violent image in Palestinian (and Palestinian solidarity) film. I would focus on the use of opacity— the intentional withholding of information, uses of silences and enigmatic images as a means of establishing relationships of equality between viewer and viewed. These works are a direct challenge to the notion of the documentary as a purveyor of information, but still rely on its privileged relationship to the “truth” or the real world. Relatedly, I will focus on the films of Kamal Aljafari.
11:00 - 12:15
Voice and Narration
Alisa Lebow: (researcher/University of Sussex, z.Zt. Berlin)
One for All: First Person Films from the Egyptian Revolution
This essay attempts to understand and account for the distinct emergence of first person documentaries after the 2011 uprising in Egypt. Looking back at the history of revolutionary film one does not see the emergence of the personal camera as a site of revolutionary expression until this current wave, given especially that revolutions have always been conceived of as collective movements. Why and how the first person has come to be articulated in this present case will be of primary concern for this chapter. Analysis of recent key first person documentaries from Egypt, including but not limited to Moug (Ahmed Nour, 2012), Arij: Scent of Revolution (Viola Shafik, 2014), Little Eagles (Mohamed Rashad, in-progress) and Happily Ever After (Nada Riyadh, in- progress) will form the basis of the discussion which will benefit from interviews of each of these filmmakers reflecting on the topic as part of the interactive data base documentary Filming Revolution (Lebow, 2015).
Viola Shafik (filmmaker/researcher/Ludwig Maximilian University):
Defying the Voice of Authority: Egyptian Documentarists between 1956 and 1982
State-sponsored Egyptian documentary of the 1950s and 60s relied heavily on the rhetorical mode and the voice-over commentary following the Griersonian model. It was only in the 1970s, in the wake of the student revolt that a new generation of filmmakers adopted a new film form inspired by the Third Cinema and direct cinema movements refusing or deconstructing the voice over as a structuring device, a development that evolved into a generational conflict within the National Film Center involving people, resources and doctrines. My paper will focus on exemplary films by old- school directors Saad Nadim and Salah al-Tuhami as opposed to Khairy Beshara and Hashim al- Nahas as representatives of the then new generation.
Lunch break 12:15-13:00
13:00 - 14:45
Mohamad Soueid (commissioning editor and producer al-Arabiyya/filmmaker/author, Dubai):Documenting Lebanon
When I chose this title I intended to depict the history of documentary filmmaking in Lebanon. However, when I started to write my essay I found the title intriguing: Is “Documenting” necessari- ly linked to documentary practices? Or is it really a task related to the film historians? In a broader sense it is related to history as a whole, more properly to the history of Lebanon. But are documentary films the mere tools/references to accomplish such a task, i.e. to reconstruct the history of Le- banon through documentary films? I, eventually, have assumed that fiction films could be/and would become in the course of time documentary references in telling the history of a country and its communities. In fact, actually any written document or any visual material, a film frame or a pie- ce of paper used in a film should be considered a contribution to the mentioned task.
Ahmed Bedjaoui (director of Algerian Film Fund/researcher/professor, University of Algiers, Algeria)
Documentaries Questioning History
France, the former colonizer and the Algerian insurgents waged a veritable war of images that be- gan in 1832 and continued beyond July 1962.
The representation of contemporary history (in particular when related to the Algerian national libe- ration war) is a central question that raises controversial debate in Algerian cinema. A large amount of documentary films (among which we can associate La Bataille d’Alger) demonstrate admirably that the secret of the cinematic narrative applied to contemporary history resides in a magical mixture somewhere between documentary and fiction, while using an analytical approach rather than a purely descriptive one.
Olivier Hadouchi (film curator, Paris, independent researcher associated to IRCAV/Paris 3/ Sorbonne Nouvelle)
Cinema and the Struggle of Women in Algeria
In this paper I want to remind of the way how cinema has tackled the women's question in Algeria through documentaries shot in different periods, like in Elles as well as Algériennes, 30 ans après by Ahmed Lallem, Lettre à ma sœur by Habiba Djahnine. My discussion will include a passage that is dedicated to the memory of female struggle during the war of independence and the way how women were dealt with after 1962 by Assia Djebbar or in Barberousse mes sœurs by Hassen Bouabdellah.
14:45 - 15:30
Round Table with Film Professionals, Cimatheque (Cairo) and Dox-Box (Damscus/Berlin)
Filmmakers Ali Essai and Mohamad Soueid as well as film initiative representatives Yasmin Desouki (Cimatheque) and Marion Schmidt (Dox-Box) will lead an open discussion on historical lessons and prospects of development.
Screening Filmmuseum Modernisms:
presented by Ali Essafi/Viola Shafik
- Village Doctor/tabib fi-l-aryaf von Khairy Beshara (1975, Ägypten, 20 min)
- Machines Revolution/thawrat al-makkan von Madkur Thabet (1967, Ägypten, 7 min)
- Return to Agadir/Retour à Agadir von Mohamed Afify (1967, Marokko, 10 min) - Horizons/afaq von Shadi Abdessalam (1972, Ägypten, 39 min)
Documentary Film in Lebanon bevor and after the Electronic Turn:
presented by Mohamad Soueid
- The Story of a Village and a War /hikayat qarya wa harb by Maroun Baghdadi (1978, Lebanon, 24 min)
- Cinema Fouad (1993, Lebanon, 60 min) by Mohamed Soueid
Reference / Quellennachweis:
CONF: Histories of Arab Documentary (München, 27-29 Nov 17). In: ArtHist.net, Oct 17, 2017. <https://arthist.net/archive/16503>.